Cheers, Fire Brand
I might be misinterpreting, but the whole "I prefer men" thing seems pretty easy for me to understand. I feel like I can agree that labeling as 'gay' would be too narrow of a scope in that case, so the logical thing to do would be to explain the male preference, as you've done. Maybe this isn't my place to ask, but does that typically not go well, hence the aversion to the topic/definition in general?
Well, that would be the logical approach. The problem is that the word 'preference' implies choice and there are a lot of very angry "militant gays" (as some would call them) that have a big issue with so much as hinting at the thought that choice is involved in the matter.
It's nature/nurture, an argument as old as any other...many people are insistent that they're born gay. I think they're(/we're, I'm) just open minded enough to accept the possibility and pursue the option due to general interest. They end up liking it (physical sensations which objectively feel good, and then the parts of the experience that they subjectively like such as the overall concept of what they're doing) and conclude that because they like it more, it must be how they are. Why is this necessary? Why can't one just acknowledge that they are open to and enjoy something without needing to completely dedicate themselves to the label (and often associated stereotypes as well)?
I can't speak for everyone, but I do know a bunch of "straight" guys who feel the above applies to them. They've done both, they prefer women. They choose to be straight.
(consider that biologically, everyone is "straight enough" to procreate - otherwise, one is not fulfilling a reason for existing...this isn't a bad thing, and isn't meant to offend...one isn't a failure for not procreating...we assign higher-level meanings to our existence via our society)
This issue is rather complex because of how firmly attached people are to labels. A big part of the fight for marriage equality is statements that people are born gay and it's not able to be changed. I agree, it can't be changed because it doesn't exist - we're people, we like certain physical sensations and some of us form relationships with the same gender...I don't really understand the need for labeling this behaviour to recognize it as being different at all.