Thanks for the reply.
I did buy it new, but unfortunately the return policy at EliteKeyboards is that they don't accept returns. I think they do repairs, but I think that's only for serious problems. I could email them, though.
Maybe I could sell it in the classifieds to someone who doesn't care about this type of stuff, and put the money towards a new one? Although that seems like a little too much time and effort put into a problem that isn't really much of a real problem..