There is no wrong or right way to do it. Just distribute them as you see fit, as per the instructions. With the original blue keycap, we didn't even know for sure that more than one person was involved for the longest time. demik was the one who let that cat out of the bag,
here. Then, as far as I can tell, demik claimed to be sending the rest of them to DanGWanG, who had already received a mystery keycap. So really, who was it that ruined the spirit and intent of this? Whatever happened to them once they left demik's hands remains a mystery, as no one else posted here that they received any, until the new ones showed up. Transparency of who was doing what with them was never a requirement, as it was supposed to be a secret.
If you doubt my words, read through every post in this thread.