All the work involved, you might as well just buy another keyboard in the color you want..
this isn't like a kmac.. where the base price would be a barrier.
I think it is more of a diy mentality, to produce something that is unique and different. It's fun to produce something which cannot be bought right off the shelf.
He's gonna say that... Up until actually having to desolder all them leds.. the poker's pcb isn't durable either, so pad lifting chance is high.. then he's not gonna know how to use the solder sucker properly, and make a mess, and short some pins..
hahahahahahha... well, the learning experience is worth it certainly..
I actually found that the expensive boards can be more difficult to solder. Many of them have a thick copper grounding plate within the PCB which pulls away the heat from your soldering iron. At least with a cheap PCB, you can run your soldering iron at a much lower temperature. The only time I had trouble with pad lifting, was when I ran my iron way too hot on a cheap board. At that time, I was using the same adjustable iron which I have in my eBay collection (which is why I made that collection), and I had the iron set to 350*C. When I set the iron down to 300*C, there were no troubles, and the solder still flowed very easy.
I just looked up the Poker II PCB, and you can see the solder pads for the LED's. With a chisel tip soldering iron, you can heat both pads at the same time, and pull out the LED's very easily. A solder sucker may not even be required either, as both pads (with some paste flux) can just be re-heated, and a new LED can be inserted. I am guessing that setting the iron to 315* would get the job done without any risk of pad lifting. This is all assuming that the PCB does not have a thick grounding plate, in which case, you would have to heat the board before doing soldering work.
And that's true, like you said, it will be a learning process. Every geek needs to learn how to pick up his soldering iron eventually, and it's better on the cheap PCB, than a more expensive one.

Edit: I actually found this, which has quite a lot of info:
https://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=42824.0