I just went through this process myself. I never bought high end headphones before so I did a bit of research. And I bought them because I listen to a ton of music, while I'm playing StarCraft 2 and usually when I'm doing anything else.
I used
this link as sort of a primer on headphones. Much like the mechanical keyboard thread where the OP drops lots of general knowledge, I found this to be the same thing.
Then I saw
this list and started hunting down some of the headphones to listen to. I've heard the following:
[indent]My roommate had these and I got to listen to them. I really liked how they sounded and the pads are ultra comfortable. I don't exactly remember the sound quality since this was a few months back so forgive me. The pads were either real leather or a really good fake. The headphones are closed back. However, they're SO BIG. I really had an issue with the size and weight. I kinda felt like I was working at the airport tarmac and had those ear protectors on. Or the big ass ear muffs they had at WCS or any other event. The price was a bit steep for me when I was looking again recently.
These headphones are closed back and have noise cancelling so it seems like you're in a vacuum. The sound is really warm and rich. The bass is really nice as well. The cups are comfortable but a little tight around the ears and they seem to pick up a lot of the oils in your skin. My issue with these is that for the price I'm paying, the construction seemed a bit flimsy and it was just not in my budget. Also, if you have these on, you're not listening to anything else. So if you're looking for something in the office or at home that's fine, but anywhere in public and you won't hear ANY outside noise.
You can listen to these at Best Buy or Micro Center. Or if you're lucky and have a Bose store at the mall, they'll have these as well.
This was my second choice for headphones. Really clear, good amount of bass without being overkill; it was a clear and crisp sound. They are also closed back so the outside sound is muffled but the music sounds great. The cups are huge and very comfortable on your head. They are a bit big though, so a bit of extra weight might be an issue. And again, you can't really hear any outside noise. The price point on these was in my budget range of about $100.
You can listen to these at Best Buy as well.
I bought these after listening to 2 songs. They're amazing. They're nice and light. And despite what I've read online about the cups being too hard, I think they're the most comfortable headphones I've ever worn. The sound? They're open back so it's almost like you're on stage with the artists when they play. The bass is just right and the music sounds very natural and breathes. So in other words, you can hear what's going on around you as well as the music. I was blown away by the sound to be honest. However, the HD 280s were a very close 2nd. These headphones were right in my budget zone.
I got these at a specialty store in Ohio. They had a pair that I could demo. If you want to try a pair, you can use
this link to try and find a place near you that sells Grados. You can see if they demo as well.
Now I heard that Guitar Centers carry a lot of good headphones that are listed in the Lifehacker list but that they don't allow you try them on. I'm sure you can go and find out yourself but I got lucky and found all the pairs I wanted.