Why does the liquor have to be American made?
I would recommend a nice single malt scotch that's made in Scotland. One of my favorites, that would be in your price range, is the Balvenie Doublewood 12 y.o.

If your gift has to be American, because you are giving it to a Republican or Tea Party person, then I would suggest California Cabernet. Go American red wine, instead of liquor, since there are no really excellent American liquors.
But you would do well with a nice bottle of California Cab. Or better yet, a case. That would make anybody happy if you gave it as a gift. Just remember, politicians have to declare any gift over $50, so make sure your Republican friends file the proper paperwork.